When Holidays Bring Mixed Feel…

When Holidays Bring Mixed Feelings: Navigating Family and Expectations

The holidays tend to come wrapped in sparkle and expectation.
We’re told it’s “the most wonderful time of the year,” yet for many people, it’s also the most complicated.

In my therapy for holiday stress in Charleston, I often hear stories of dread mixed with longing — people craving connection while bracing for conflict or exhaustion.
You can hold both. Joy and grief can coexist. So can love and frustration.

1. Notice the Stories You’re Carrying

So much stress comes from trying to live up to an imagined version of the holidays — the one where everyone gets along, every dish turns out perfectly, and no one argues.
When those ideals collide with real life, guilt or disappointment rush in.

Try asking yourself:

“What actually matters to me this season?”

Once you name that, it’s easier to let go of the rest.

2. Prepare, Don’t Pretend

If family gatherings tend to be tense, pretending “this year will be different” without changing anything usually backfires.
Instead, go in with a plan:

Choose who you’ll sit next to or when you’ll take a break outside.

Decide ahead of time which topics you’ll politely step away from.

Have a short grounding routine ready — deep breaths, counting objects in the room, or texting a supportive friend.

Preparation is not pessimism; it’s self-protection.

3. Let “Good Enough” Be the Goal

Perfection sneaks into the holidays disguised as tradition. But no one remembers spotless floors — they remember warmth.
Simplify where you can. Buy the store-bought dessert, skip the extra event, use paper plates if it means more peace.

Every “no” to excess is a “yes” to presence.

4. Honor What’s Missing

For many, the holidays awaken grief — of people, time, or versions of life that have changed.
Instead of pushing those feelings away, create a quiet ritual: light a candle, play a song, or share a memory aloud.
Acknowledging what hurts often brings more comfort than avoiding it.

If this season brings more stress than sparkle, you’re not alone.
Therapy can help you set boundaries, process mixed emotions, and find your own definition of peace — one that fits your real life, not the Hallmark version.

Quercus Counseling — Serving the greater Charleston, SC area in person and virtually.
Learn more at www.QuercusCounseling.com

Photo of Brooke Dooley, Licensed Therapist serving Charleston and Mount Pleasant, SC

About the Author –Brooke Dooley, LPC

Brooke Dooley is a licensed therapist with over 25 years of experience helping adults and couples in the Charleston area, including Mount Pleasant, Sullivan's Island and Isle of Palms. Her counseling practice focuses on improving communication, strengthening relationships, and guiding clients toward emotional resilience and lasting change.

She offers both in-person and virtual therapy sessions to make care accessible across South Carolina. Learn more about her approach or schedule a consultation at quercuscounseling.com.

Specialties: Anxiety • Depression • Relationship Issues • Couples Therapy • Life and Career Coaching • Life Transitions

Previous Post
When You Can’t Switch Off: The Cost of Constant Productivity